| | |  Editorials | Opinions 
Should TV 'Narco-Novelas' be Banned in Latin America?
 Patrick Corcoran - mexidata.info
go to original
March 27, 2010
| | Popular Colombian narco-telenovelas such as "El Cartel de los Sapos" are shown on television channels around the world. | |
Panamanian President Ricardo Martinelli opened up a minor controversy earlier this year when he criticized the popular Colombian soap operas for glamorizing the life of a drug lord. "These telenovelas are inflicting great damage to the moral fiber of our country," the president reportedly said in a meeting with media heavyweights in his nation. He also ominously referred to the possible passage of a restrictive law if the broadcast titans neglected to regulate the content of their programming.
The concern over the shows is misguided for a number of reasons.
The first is that it takes a willfully jaundiced view of the novelas to suggest that they are selling drug culture as a risk-free entree into the high life. Probably the most famous of Colombia's narco-novelas is El Cartel de los Sapos (in English, The Cartel of the Toads). If one were to sum up the theme of the series in a single word, it would be betrayal. Indeed, "toad" in Colombia is slang for snitch, and the inevitable progression from friendship to betrayal is written into the series' theme song. Business interests nearly always trump personal ties, with childhood friends turning on each other with the same predictability (though with much greater heartache) one sees in a Globetrotters’ defeat of the Generals.
Beyond the thematic elements, El Cartel de los Sapos has one notable fixation that also runs contra to Martinelli’s thesis. The body cavity search one evidently receives on his way into federal prison in the US is handled with such excruciating detail and mind-numbing repetition that one feels violated himself halfway through the first season. This is, of course, not the sort of detail that one includes to entice impressionable youths into a life of shipping cocaine to the US.
As one would expect with all the back-stabbing and bottom-inspecting, the drug lords are portrayed as a perennially fearful, overwhelmingly unhappy bunch. Sure, there are some beautiful, only partially dressed ladies walking around their ranches, and the protagonists treat seven-figure sums of dollars with roughly the same reverence that most of us reserve for pencils or bread crumbs, but even a not particularly careful viewing of El Cártel reveals the drug lord’s life to be a little more than years of bloodshed, anxiety, and depression, all culminating with a prison guard's latexed fingers being jammed into your rectum.
Even if we concede Martinelli’s point that the soap operas offer an overly glamorized portrait of life as a modern-day Escobar, television is a tangential element of Latin America’s security problem. If Martinelli could wave a magic wand and the Colombian shows vanished from the airwaves forever, the drivers of the drug trade (notably the American prohibition, the huge American market, and the stratospheric profit margins) would still be in place, which means drug traffickers would continue running amuck around Latin America.
As an illustration of this fact, consider Mexico, where drug culture basically doesn’t figure into the nation’s television programming whatsoever (aside from, of course, the nightly news, where it unfortunately occupies a prominent role). Despite the barren landscape for Mexican crime drama, the world’s most violent city is Juárez, and public security is ever more problematic. Mexico's government hasn't (as far as we know) prohibited narco-novelas, but it does demonstrate that the evils of the drug trade cannot be addressed in any meaningful way by censoring TV programs.
Furthermore, if the US is any indication, the prevalence of narco-novelas could be taken as good news. By the time a violent social force reaches the point of cultural currency in which it spawns movies and television shows, it’s often already in a descendent phase. When the Godfather appeared in the 1970s, the mob was already less powerful than in generations past. Twenty-five years later, the decline of the mafia was a major subplot of The Sopranos.
The five year-run of Miami Vice coincided with the decline of the city as the vital entry point of all Colombian cocaine into the US. The same is true of inner-city violence surrounding the crack boom; when Boyz in the Hood and Menace II Society arrived at movie theaters in the early 1990s, crime numbers were already on their way down, and the US stood at the beginning of a two-decade decline in violent crime.
Presumably, the ideal replacement to all these narco-novelas for Martinelli would be 24-style television in which selfless, heroic government officials overcome any obstacle to defeat the bad guys. I actually do think it would be a positive development to have more Spanish-language programs in which the government represented the forces of good, but that’s not to be confused with actually tamping down on organized crime. This, rather than the TV schedule, is what should concern governments like Martinelli's.
Patrick Corcoran (corcoran25(at)hotmail.com) is a writer who resides in Torreón, Coahuila. He blogs at Gancho (http://www.ganchoblog.blogspot.com/). |
|
| |
Vallarta Weddings
Tell a Friend
Site Map
Print this Page
Email Us